作者：boxuewushu
发表时间：2008-3-14 17:05:37

华东师大张利权、吴建平发表的SCI论文，被主编定性为剽窃，因此被撤稿。但是张吴与主编争辩，说他们的行为不是剽窃，属于引用。试问，该文是剽窃吗？
下面是主编的撤稿申明（出处：http://linkinghub.elsevier.com/retrieve/pii/S016920460600260x；doi:10.1016/j.landurbplan.2006.11.002）
Retraction Notice

Retraction Notice to “A GIS-based gradient analysis of urban landscape pattern of Shanghai metropolitan area, China” [Landscape Urban Plan. 69 (2004) 1–16]

Liquan Zhanga, , , Jianping Wub, Yu Zhena and Jiong Shub
aState Key Laboratory of Estuarine and Coastal Research, East China Normal University, Shanghai 200062, China
bOpen Laboratory of Geographical Information Science of Chinese Education Ministry, East China Normal University, Shanghai 200062, China

Available online 12 January 2007.

Refers to:  RETRACTED: A GIS-based gradient analysis of urban landscape pattern of Shanghai metropolitan area, China
Landscape and Urban Planning, Volume 69, Issue 1, 15 July 2004, Pages 1-16
Liquan Zhang, Jianping Wu, Yu Zhen and Jiong Shu
Abstract | Abstract + References | PDF (587 K) 

This article has been retracted.

Reason: This article substantially copies an article by Matthew Luck and Jianguo Wu, “A gradient analysis of urban landscape pattern: a case study from the Phoenix metropolitan region, Arizona, USA” published in Landscape Ecology 17 (4), pp. 327–339, 2002. The authors Zhang et al. have indicated in response that this does not amount to plagiarism because the article by Matthew Luck and Jianguo Wu was cited in their paper. In my view, the amount copied exceeds the usual purpose of citation (to refer to prior relevant work) and amounts to plagiarism.

Jon Rodiek
Editor-in-Chief
Landscape and Urban Planning

［此帖子已被 boxuewushu 在 2008-3-14 17:18:01 编辑过］

作者：zxg979713
发表时间：2008-3-14 19:21:24

感觉不是，也许在思路上有点雷同

发表您的观点，进入该主题参与讨论...

作者：春风不度
发表时间：2008-3-14 21:57:16

　想看更多更好的图书资料到这里来：http://www.*******.cn/bbs/viewthread.php?tid=39237&fromuid=117946

发表您的观点，进入该主题参与讨论...

作者：zhuanyouxia
发表时间：2008-7-10 16:02:38

已经查证过了，张利权和吴健平的这篇论文不但是剽窃，而且还一稿两投，同时发表在Landscape and Urban Planning（2004, 69:1-16）和《植物生态学报》(2004,28(1):78-85)。尽管目前国内《植物生态学报》的主编
尚未发表撤稿申明，但是国外主编的撤稿申明已经发表在Landscape and Urban Planning,Volume 2007,79(3-4):401. 

国外主编的申明可以从网址看到：http://linkinghub.elsevier.com/retrieve/pii/S016920460600260X 

两篇（英、中）文稿，见如下附件：

［此帖子已被 zhuanyouxia 在 2008-7-10 16:14:04 编辑过］

［此帖子已被 zhuanyouxia 在 2008-7-10 16:17:44 编辑过］

发表您的观点，进入该主题参与讨论...